Meta Agrees to New Safety Features for Young Users

Meta Child Safety Features

California v. Meta Platforms, Inc. reached a settlement as Meta agrees to new safety features for young users. The case is seen by legal observers as historic, with some comparing it to past litigation against Big Tobacco companies. Meta was accused of knowingly contributing to teen mental health problems, especially adolescent girls with body image issues, by using deceptive practices to addict teenage users of Facebook and Instagram. Meta was also accused of violating federal data privacy laws by utilizing digital tracking tools to collect children’s online data without permission. Now, the case has been resolved with a settlement: Meta will implement features to protect the most vulnerable users of Facebook and Instagram. This is in addition to $17 billion that Meta has agreed to pay to states that filed the lawsuit.

California v. Meta Platforms: Social Media Addiction Lawsuit in Federal Court

California v. Meta Platforms, Inc. received national attention and was heard in a federal court in Oakland, CA. The lawsuit was filed by 51 attorneys general, including California Attorney General Rob Bonta.

The lawsuit centered around children’s social media addiction. Both Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg and Instagram CEO Adam Mosseri were expected to testify during the trial. Mosseri did testify before the case was settled in the trial’s second week.

Meta was accused of violating the Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act (COPPA). Meta was also accused of violating multiple California consumer protection laws: California’s False Advertising Law (FAL) and California’s Unfair Competition Law (UCL).

Lawsuit: Meta Targeted Underage Users of Facebook and Instagram

According to the states that filed the lawsuit, Meta knew its social media products were addictive and harmful to children – and yet the company continued to promote them. In fact, Meta allegedly designed its social media platforms – Facebook and Instagram – to addict teenage users. Meta was also accused of misleading parents about the dangers posed to underage users, which caused significant harm to an entire generation of young people.

Megan O’Neill, the California deputy attorney general, told jurors in her opening statement that Meta tries to “hook users, hold them for as long as they can, harvest their data, and then hide the truth from the public when making public statements.” She cited an internal Meta study, which was titled, “The Young Ones Are the Best Ones.”

Even the efforts that Meta supposedly undertook to limit teen use of its products were largely ineffective. Although Meta has a policy that bars children under the age of 13 from accessing its social media platforms, kids have reportedly been able to get around the restriction by registering with false information.

Meta Accused of Harvesting Data from Teen Users

In addition to intentionally designing its platform features to addict teen users, Meta allegedly violated federal data privacy laws by acquiring underage users’ browsing data and personal information without parental consent. Meta’s teen marketing strategies and data collection practices are connected: the company’s algorithm can target teenagers precisely because Meta allegedly monitors users’ online behavior and collects their data. This data is then fed into the algorithm to generate personalized feeds and targeted advertisements.

Settlement: Meta Agrees to Pay $17 Billion in Damages

Meta avoided a jury verdict at trial by reaching a settlement, which requires Meta to pay $17 billion to states over the next decade. California will receive the largest settlement amount: up to $2 billion. The settlement will also lead to real protections for kids who use Facebook and Instagram, which is something that would have been more difficult for a court to impose if the trial had reached a verdict. That’s because courts aren’t really equipped to craft detailed restrictions on tech companies.

Settlement: Meta Must Implement Features to Protect Kids Against Mental Health Harms Online

Perhaps the most important aspect of the settlement is injunctions that will prevent Meta from designing and implementing features that cause mental health harms for children. This includes daily time limits for minors who use Facebook and Instagram; a limit on overnight use of the social media apps; tools for parents to more easily supervise their children’s social media use; strict age-verification tools; and more. In the broadest terms, the settlement requires Meta to limit teens’ social media use and go further to protect teens against the dangers of social media.

Importantly, these safety features will be the default setting for every underage user of Facebook and Instagram. Moreover, they can only be changed with parental approval.

Additionally, an independent auditor will monitor Meta and make sure that the tech company is adhering to the terms of the settlement. This oversight will last for five years.

Time Limits

The Meta deal could reshape rules for children online. For example, Meta has agreed to impose strict, two-hour limits on teen users of Facebook and Instagram. This could have a positive effect on teenage social media addiction since teen users will essentially be forced to log off occasionally.

Along those same lines, underage users of Facebook and Instagram will receive prompts to pause use of the social media platforms.

Notifications During School Hours

The settlement blocks Facebook and Instagram from sending notifications to teen users during school hours so that children will not be distracted when they are supposed to be learning.

Non-Personalized Feed

One of the requirements of the Meta settlement is that the company must give teenage users the option to have a non-personalized, chronological feed appear on their screen when they log into Facebook or Instagram.

However, the settlement does not require Meta to make a non-personalized feed the default setting. Instead, teens who use Facebook or Instagram will need to affirmatively choose this option – or risk being bombarded with targeted advertisements and article links. This is particularly problematic in the context of teenage social media behavior because adolescents are not likely to choose to take a break from Facebook or Instagram on their own.

Age Verification

Another requirement of the settlement is that Meta must take steps to verify children’s ages before those children can use Facebook or Instagram.

However, the age verification requirement imposed by the settlement could be difficult to enforce. That’s because kids can be very good at getting onto social media apps without parental approval. They can also be adept at finding ways around age settings.

Online Bullying

The settlement requires Meta to implement content control measures to prevent online bullying.

Plastic Surgery Filters

The settlement calls for a ban on plastic surgery filters on the social media apps.

Autoplay Feature

Although not required by the settlement, Meta will provide parents with the option to turn off the autoplay feature on Instagram and Facebook so that child users are not bombarded by more and more content as they use the platforms. Parents will also be able to opt in to a feature that turns off the algorithm targeting underage users with personalized content.

Meta Agrees to Study the Effects of Social Media on Teenagers’ Mental Health

As part of the settlement, Meta has also pledged to continue reviewing and improving safety measures to protect teens against mental health harms on the company’s social media apps. This includes a promise by Meta to create an independent research foundation tasked with studying how social media affects teenagers’ psychological wellbeing.

Social media has long been believed to cause serious mental health problems for teenagers, including anxiety and depression. Adolescents are especially vulnerable to the harms caused by social media use because their brains are still developing. Beyond that, teenagers are more likely to desire approval from others, which can impact how they interpret and perceive what they see online.

Contact the Los Angeles Data Privacy Lawyers at Tauler Smith LLP

Tauler Smith LLP is a California law firm that represents clients in consumer protection cases, including data privacy and data fraud claims. We’ve helped plaintiffs file individual lawsuits and class actions in both state and federal courts. If you were a victim of online data theft, or if your personal information was used by a company without your consent, we can help you get financial compensation.

Call or email us today to explore your legal options.