Meta Settles Social Media Addiction Lawsuit

Meta Social Media Addiction Lawsuit

A historic legal case recently made major headlines: Meta Settles Social Media Addiction Lawsuit. Meta, the parent company of both Facebook and Instagram, was accused of intentionally addicting underage users and negatively impacting their mental health. A coalition of attorneys general filed a lawsuit against Meta in California federal court, with possible damages of more than $1 trillion. Shortly after trial began, Meta agreed to settle the case for $17 billion. This is the largest Big Tech settlement in U.S. history, as well as one of the largest consumer protection lawsuits ever. As part of the settlement, Meta also agreed to implement new safety features to protect kids who use the company’s social media platforms, which could have significant consequences for teen mental health policies and child privacy protection laws.

Social Media Addiction Case: California v. Meta Platforms, Inc.

The social media addiction case, California v. Meta Platforms, Inc., was brought by 51 jurisdictions, including attorneys general from 47 states and Washington, D.C. Four states took the lead and represented all other states in the Meta lawsuit: California, Colorado, Kentucky, and New Jersey. The lawsuit was triggered when Meta basically dared authorities to take them to court by refusing to protect children who used Facebook and Instagram. Meta was accused of violating the Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act (COPPA), a federal law that protects personal information of minors under the age of 13. Meta was also accused of violating state consumer protection laws (e.g., California’s Unfair Competition Law and California’s False Advertising Law).

The case was heard in a California federal court: the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California. Trial was expected to last several weeks, but it ended abruptly when Meta reached a settlement to resolve the claims. If the trial had continued, Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg was expected to testify.

Lawsuit: Meta Targeted and Endangered Teen Users of Facebook and Instagram

Meta was accused of intentionally harming teen social media users and violating federal privacy protection laws. The chief prosecutor in the case was California attorney general Rob Bonta. He accused Meta of putting profits before the safety of its youngest users. At a press conference, Bonta said, “We have proof that Meta knows that Instagram is harmful to a significant percentage of teenagers, especially teen girls.”

Meta was specifically accused of intentionally trying to “hook” young users on Facebook and Instagram. According to the attorneys general who filed the lawsuit, Meta executives made decisions when designing the social media platforms based on driving excessive use and endless scrolling online by underage users. At trial, Meta was accused of implementing addictive features like infinite scrolling, personalized recommendations, and constant notifications to keep young users coming back to the social media platforms. Moreover, witnesses testified that the tech company knew about the potential for serious harm to teenage users, including anxiety, depression, and sleep problems.

The states that filed the lawsuit against Meta also accused the tech company of intentionally misleading the public about its policies, as well as the degree of harm caused to young users. According to one of the attorneys general who brought the lawsuit against Meta, the tech giant “intentionally deceived the public about addictive and harmful design features that have wreaked havoc on youth mental health.”

Whistleblowers: Meta Knew It Was Harming Young Users

The allegations against Meta were precipitated by several whistleblowers who used to work for Meta. At the beginning of the trial, the plaintiffs introduced internal emails showing that Meta executives knew how harmful the platform was for kids. Shockingly, some of Meta’s documents explicitly referred to the targeting of teenage users as “the overall company goal.”

Additionally, witnesses testified that Meta executives were obsessed with increasing user numbers at any costs, including severe harms to those users. For example, former Meta employee and whistleblower Arturo Bejar said that the company’s own internal studies proved that teenagers were highly susceptible to mental health harms – and yet the company did nothing to protect kids who used the social media platforms.

Attorneys General: Meta Illegally Collected Data from Millions of Children 

Meta was also accused of collecting underage users’ personal data without proper parental consent, which constituted a serious violation of federal law. Specifically, it is a violation of the Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act (COPPA), which prohibits companies from using online tracking technologies to monitor minors and acquire their data. When the Meta social media addiction case settled, roughly $500 million was connected to the data privacy violations.

Settlement: Meta Must Pay $17 Billion in Damages in Social Media Addiction Case

To settle the social media addiction lawsuit, Meta agreed to pay $17 billion in damages and make massive changes to its Facebook and Instagram platforms. The money will go to a consortium of states, with the payout extending over a period of 10 years. California is set to receive the highest settlement payout at between $1.5 billion and $2 billion, followed closely by states like New York, Illinois, and New Jersey.

According to Meta, 30% of the total settlement amount will be released to states only if TikTok and YouTube implement similar measures to protect child users. YouTube is owned by Google, so the conditional settlement terms would also apply to that company.

Settlement: Meta Must Implement New Safety Features for Underage Users

The Meta settlement requires the tech giant to create new software features to protect teen users on Facebook and Instagram. These child safety features will include:

  • Time limits: A two-hour daily limit for underage users. Child users will also be prompted to take a break after a long scroll on the app.
  • Late-night restrictions: Children will not have access to the apps from midnight to 6am.
  • No use during school hours: Push notifications on the apps will be disabled while kids are in school.
  • No beauty filters: The use of image beauty filters that mimic cosmetic surgery will be disabled on the apps.
  • No more “likes”: The total number of users who have “liked” a post will be hidden.

While Meta expressed concern that self-regulating with child safety features would put the company at a competitive disadvantage to companies like TikTok and YouTube, they ultimately agreed to adopt the safeguards.

Additionally, Meta must submit reports and turn over documents to an independent auditor who will make sure that the company is complying with settlement requirements.

Critics: Meta Settlement Doesn’t Go Far Enough to Protect Teen Social Media Users

There has been some criticism that the Meta settlement did not go far enough to protect teenage users of Facebook and Instagram. For instance, state attorneys general were initially looking to get $1.4 trillion, so the actual settlement is a small fraction of that original amount. To put the settlement numbers in perspective, Meta generates more than $200 billion in annual revenues, and the company reported profits of more than $16 billion last quarter alone.

Another big criticism of the Meta settlement is that the requirements for Meta to protect teen users will end after 10 years. Similarly, the independent auditor who is supposed to oversee Meta’s compliance with the settlement will be in place for just five years. Additionally, the auditor won’t have much authority to enforce the settlement; all they can do is alert state attorneys general when Meta is failing to honor the agreement. And there doesn’t appear to be much transparency in the auditor’s findings: they will be kept private, so the public might not learn much about any future transgressions by Meta.

In fact, the Meta settlement auditor’s limited enforcement authority pales in comparison to the kind of authority that an agency like the California Privacy Protection Agency has to protect consumers’ data privacy rights and enforce state consumer privacy laws.

What Happens After the Meta Child Safety Settlement?

The Meta settlement must be approved by the court via a consent judgment. California Attorney General Rob Bonta said the settlement will ensure that social media is less dangerous for kids going forward. According to Bonta, the transformations to Facebook and Instagram will significantly reduce risk of harm to underage users. Legal experts have echoed that sentiment, with particular praise for the settlement because it forces Meta to adopt child safety policies that might have been difficult to achieve through legislation.

Although the Meta settlement does not require the tech giant to admit to any wrongdoing, the fact that Meta and other social media companies are at least acknowledging the problem of teen addiction on their platforms represents a major step forward for child safety advocates. And many states and jurisdictions are taking notice. Although Texas was not one of the states involved in the settlement, the Lone Star State reached a separate agreement with Meta to receive $1 billion as compensation for similar claims over child safety. Ken Paxton, the attorney general of Texas, said the settlement will accomplish a lot: “The idea here is to want to protect children from being exposed to material they don’t want to be exposed to. And also to limit the time – because there has been a lot said about the addiction to social media. So, we are trying to put more of the control in parenting instead of just having an open platform where kids of any age can get exposed to things they shouldn’t.”

There is also hope is that the Meta settlement will lead to a domino effect across the board for every social media platform. After the settlement was announced, Meta called for other social media companies like TikTok and YouTube to adopt similar measures to protect underage users.

Social Media and Artificial Intelligence

What does the future hold for social media platforms in the wake of the Meta child safety settlement? One clue might come from the increasing prevalence of Artificial Intelligence (AI) and machine-learning systems. Many AI companies paid close attention to the case and are taking steps to inoculate themselves against liability. OpenAI recently launched ChatGPT for Teens, which is tailored for adolescent users and features parental controls and built-in “quiet hours.” The company also announced an initiative to “keep teens safer” online by providing grants for research into AI and teenagers.

Lawsuits Against Other Social Media Companies: TikTok, Google, Snapchat, and YouTube

Meta is one of several tech companies that has come under scrutiny for online fraud & surveillance, harvesting consumer data, and causing serious mental health harms to teen users. Other online companies and social media platforms that face legal action over those claims include Google, Snapchat, TikTok, and YouTube. In fact, there are currently thousands of lawsuits against social media companies with similar allegations about child safety and data privacy violations.

Major social media platforms are certainly paying close attention to the Meta settlement. Some have already taken action to avoid similarly large damages awards in other lawsuits. For example, TikTok recently reached a $100 million settlement in Alabama to set time limits for underage users of the popular platform. 

Additionally, a recent data privacy lawsuit against Meta did go to trial in New Mexico, where a jury found the company liable for violating consumer protection laws and also unlawfully collecting user data.

Another recent case was brought by the Department of Justice against TikTok for violating federal children’s privacy laws. The case was resolved with a $400 million settlement.

Contact the California Data Privacy Attorneys at Tauler Smith LLP

Tauler Smith LLP represents plaintiffs in California data privacy cases. If you visited a website or used a social media app like Facebook or Instagram, it’s possible that your online activity was tracked and your personal information was acquired without consent. Our Los Angeles data privacy lawyers can help you stop the unauthorized collection and sharing of your online data. We can also help you get financial compensation. Call or email us now.