A major class action lawsuit is set to proceed after a federal court in California certifies classes in Meta pixel healthcare litigation. Social media giant Meta, the parent company of Facebook and Instagram, has been accused of violating state and federal data privacy laws by unlawfully collecting patient data from healthcare-provider websites and patient portals. Confidential medical information was intercepted and then transmitted to Meta. The plaintiffs filed suit and sought to certify four (4) classes of Facebook users whose health data was allegedly collected without consent. Now, a federal court has granted the plaintiffs’ motion to certify classes, which means the case may move forward to trial.
In re Meta Pixel Healthcare: Data Privacy Class Action Against Meta in California Northern District Court
In re Meta Pixel Healthcare, the data privacy lawsuit against Meta, was filed by consumer protection lawyers in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California. Unlawful collection of the plaintiffs’ medical information allegedly occurred while they were using Meta’s social media platforms or while they were on their healthcare providers’ websites. If proven, this would be a serious violation of numerous laws, including:
- Breach of contract
- Breach of implied covenant
- Intrusion upon seclusion
- California’s Comprehensive Computer Data Access and Fraud Act (CDAFA)
- California Invasion of Privacy Act (CIPA)
- Electronic Communications Privacy Act (ECPA)
Attorneys for the plaintiffs asked the court to certify four different classes eligible for relief:
- Patient Status Button-Click Class: The group of Facebook users who visited another website and had their patient status information unlawfully obtained by Meta from a patient portal, medical appointment, bill payment, or diagnostic assessment button click.
- Patient Health Information Class: The group of Facebook users whose online communications about a doctor, medical condition, or medical treatment were obtained by Meta.
- Prescription Drug Information Class: The group of Facebook users who communicated with a prescription drug website and had their prescription information acquired by Meta.
- Patient Device Intrusion Class: The group of Facebook users who visited a healthcare provider website that installed Meta “cookies” and or tracking pixels to secretly collect their online data and then transmit it back to Meta.
What Are the Requirements for Class Action Certification Under Federal Rule 23?
Before a class action can proceed, the court must certify the class so that some of the plaintiffs can move forward with the case on behalf of a larger group. This means that the individuals who make up the “class” must be representative of the entire group.
Rule 23(a)
Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23 sets forth the criteria for certifying a class of plaintiffs in a federal class action lawsuit. First, the plaintiffs must satisfy Rule 23(a) by showing:
- Numerosity: The class is large enough that allowing all individual plaintiffs to proceed to trial and potentially testify would be impractical.
- Commonality: There are questions of law or fact common to the class.
- Typicality: Claims of the individuals being certified are typical of claims of the entire class.
- Adequacy of Representation: Certified parties will fairly and adequately represent interests of the larger class.
When it came to most of the necessary elements – e.g., numerosity, commonality, and typicality – the federal court in In re Meta Pixel Healthcare said that there was no dispute and that the plaintiffs satisfied these class certification requirements.
Rule 23(b)
Additionally, plaintiffs seeking to certify a class must satisfy Rule 23(b). This requires plaintiffs to establish that they fall into one of three categories:
- Prejudice Class Action: Some members of the group suing would be prejudiced if the case proceeded with separate individual lawsuits.
- Injunctive or Declaratory Relief Class Action: A final ruling that grants injunctive or declaratory relief would be appropriate for the entire class.
- Damages Class Action: There are questions of law or fact common to the group as a whole, and those common questions predominate over questions that might affect individual class members.
In In re Meta Pixel Healthcare, the plaintiffs sought certification under the third category: a class action that will result in an award of damages to the entire class because common questions of law or fact exist. The court observed that Meta rested its challenge to class certification mainly on this element. Meta tried to argue that the plaintiffs did not sufficiently prove that every class member was affected in the same way. For example, Meta said that there was no way to show that the web and app developers accused of unlawfully collecting users’ confidential health information were even covered by the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) or the California Confidentiality of Medical Information Act (CMIA).
The court rejected Meta’s argument, noting that the plaintiffs articulated exactly why common issues in the case predominate on a claim by claim and remedy by remedy basis.
CIPA Claims Require Class Certification in California
The plaintiffs in In re Meta Pixel Healthcare asked the court to certify a nationwide class. But claims brought under the California Invasion of Privacy Act (CIPA) and the California Comprehensive Computer Data Access and Fraud Act (CDAFA) require plaintiffs to show that there is a connection to California. For this reason, Meta challenged the eligibility of some plaintiffs for the class action.
Lawyers for the plaintiffs responded by suggesting that the court instead certify “subclasses of patients who either communicated from California or exchanged a communication with a California-based healthcare provider.” The court agreed that this narrower class would be appropriate for at least the CIPA Section 631 claim because Meta admitted that it intercepted browsing data from consumers located in California. Additionally, the court noted that there is common evidence that Meta stored patient data in the company’s data centers, including data centers located in California.
California Federal Court Certifies Classes in Data Privacy Lawsuit Against Meta
The United States District Court for the Northern District of California did not give much weight to Meta’s arguments against class certification. For example, Meta suggested that some users of healthcare providers’ websites or apps might be acting on behalf of a family member or friend. The court observed that even if this happens, it presumably happens very rarely – and that there are millions of other instances when Meta obtains healthcare data directly from the individual and without that individual’s permission.
Meta also tried to argue that it should not be held responsible for healthcare entities that use Meta’s tracking technology to collect protected health data. According to Meta, it is impossible for the tech company to keep tabs on all these other healthcare companies. However, plaintiffs’ attorneys countered by asserting that they have experts who can identify the healthcare providers who used Meta’s online tracking software. This would involve looking at the default settings on Meta’s products and sampling the data. The court agreed with the plaintiffs, finding that Meta’s argument – the case is too complex to litigate – was weak, especially in light of plaintiffs’ experts and their methodologies for identifying and examining the browsing data collected by Meta’s tracking pixels.
Lawsuit: Meta Accused of Intercepting HIPAA-Protected Health Information
As support for its argument against class certification, Meta cited Frasco v. Flo Health, another data privacy case heard in the California Northern District Court. In that case, Flo Health was accused of collecting personal health data from millions of women who used the company’s Flo Cycle & Period Tracker app. Worse, Flo Health allegedly shared that confidential data with tech companies like Meta and Google. Since this data included sensitive details about female users – such as ovulation schedules and sexual activity – the tracking and unlawful sharing of the information was seen by the court as a particularly egregious violation of California consumer privacy laws. The case against Flo Health went to trial, but it was settled just days before an expected verdict. A related lawsuit against Meta was not settled, and a jury eventually ruled against the tech company.
Frasco v. Flo Health was obviously not a “good” case or outcome for Meta. Yet the tech giant cited it as support for its class certification challenge in In re Meta Pixel Healthcare because the court previously said that Flo Health was not a medical provider and might not have to comply with Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) regulations.
Here, the court found Meta’s argument unpersuasive and distinguished the Flo Health case because that case did not involve actual medical patients. In the current case, patients clicked on buttons or made communications disclosing their medical status and healthcare needs, which may be protected by both HIPAA and the state’s primary medical privacy law, the California Confidentiality of Medical Information Act (CMIA).
How Did Meta Acquire Patient Information from Healthcare-Provider Websites?
Meta was accused of using Pixel tracking technology embedded on healthcare websites and patient portals to intercept and transmit patients’ health data, medical conditions, and site search history. All of this was allegedly done without users’ knowledge or consent.
In the context of class certification, Meta argued that it was not possible for plaintiffs to identify which specific healthcare websites might have sent the protected health data to Meta. The defendant said that class issues could not predominate over individual claims because site visitors took different actions on different sites: some clicked patient buttons to provide detailed medical information, some entered data about prescription drugs that they used, and some conducted general medical research. The patients who merely did research or who allowed family members to log onto the healthcare apps on their behalf, argued Meta, would not be covered by medical privacy statutes and should have their claims heard individually rather than as part of a class action.
Again, the California Northern District Court disagreed. The court said that it would not be difficult for individual class members to self-identify at a later stage of the trial and provide proof of the type of HIPAA-protected information they shared with healthcare-provider apps and websites, which subsequently shared the information with Meta. The court acknowledged that some class members might not technically qualify for the class because they had a family member or friend use the healthcare apps on their behalf. However, the court said that this would have only a minimal impact on the scope of the class.
Class Action: Meta Did Not Have Consent to Acquire Patients’ Private Health Information
A crucial element of the online privacy claim against Meta is that the plaintiffs did not provide affirmative consent for Meta to acquire their private health information. Meta contested class certification by arguing that it is not possible for the plaintiffs to prove consent – or lack of consent – for all users across the class. Basically, Meta said that there were many instances where perhaps at least some members of the class may have provided the requisite permission for collection of their health data. For example, some individuals may have legally consented by continuing to use certain healthcare websites even after those sites disclosed Meta’s conduct. Additionally, some individuals may have shared their own healthcare data on their personal Facebook pages, making it moot whether Meta later collected and/or disclosed that same information.
The California Northern District Court acknowledged the importance of this issue but said that it required further consideration on a claim-by-claim basis. While both the Electronic Communications Privacy Act (ECPA) and the California Invasion of Privacy Act (CIPA) stipulate that consent is an affirmative defense in privacy cases, a defendant must show that consent was “actual,” not just implied. Here, the court said that Meta’s challenge to class certification fails because determining whether Meta’s disclosures were sufficient is a question that must be resolved on a class-wide basis during summary judgement.
The federal court also rejected Meta’s argument because evidence to support class certification on this point will be largely common: Meta’s policies; instructions given by Meta to website operators; and disclosures about data acquisition made by website operators to site visitors. The court said that none of this evidence is individualized; instead, it “covers the hundreds, thousands, or tens of thousands of class members who secured healthcare from each of those entities.”
Importantly, the court also said that any information harvested by Meta from class members would have been explicitly protected by the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA). This is why, according to the plaintiffs, Meta’s contracts and disclosures explicitly promise that they will not acquire patients’ health data.
Court: Plaintiffs Have Article III Standing to Sue Meta for Collecting Confidential Medical Data
Meta also tried to argue that the plaintiffs did not have standing to sue under Article III of the U.S. Constitution: the case or controversy clause. As support, Meta cited a data privacy case previously heard by the court: Smith v. Rack Room Shoes, Inc. In that case, the court denied a motion for class certification because it could not be shown that individual class members’ browsing activity had actually been tracked; the mere presence of third-party tracking technology on the website was not enough.
Once again, the court in In re Meta Pixel Healthcare distinguished the cases and rejected Meta’s argument. The court noted that Meta allegedly made promises to plaintiffs that the company would not collect their information. The court then cited a recent decision by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals: Black v. IEC Group, which concerned an accidental disclosure of patient health information by Ameriben, a third-party administrator of employee health plans. The federal appellate court in that data privacy class action held that Ameriben promised to protect customers’ health data and then failed to follow through on that promise. This, said the court, provided a strong basis for a breach of contract claim. The court concluded that the same reasoning applies in the current case against Meta: the tech company’s failure to honor its promises not to collect users’ confidential data is a concrete injury sufficient for both a breach of contract claim and a statutory privacy claim.
Court: Meta’s Alleged “Reprehensible” Conduct May Influence Damages Award in Class Action
Meta tried to argue that class certification should be denied because there could be differences in damages sought by individual class members: some class members might want more financial compensation than others. The court quickly rejected this argument because “differences in damages rarely defeat class certification.” The court added that different types of damages – statutory damages, punitive damages, restitution, and equitable remedies – would be determined on a class-wide basis because they are subject to common proof from plaintiffs’ expert witnesses.
It’s noteworthy that the court’s discussion of damages also emphasized the alleged “reprehensibility of any conduct for which Meta might be liable.” This comes on the heels of a $17 billion settlement of a social media addiction lawsuit against Meta filed by 51 attorneys general. In that case, Meta was accused of intentionally addicting underage users to Facebook and Instagram, in addition to unlawfully collecting data from millions of children. In this case, the court said that proof of Meta’s unlawful behavior is not necessary during the class certification phase of the trial; instead, it could be more closely examined after a verdict has been reached.
Expert Testimony: Meta Intentionally Harvested Medical Data Without Permission
The court accepted the plaintiffs’ argument that questions about Meta’s intent and knowledge did not require individualized inquiries. The court pointed to extensive expert testimony in discovery about what Meta knew about its interception of healthcare-related data and when Meta knew it. Importantly, the court concluded that these questions are subject to common proof applying to all class members in the lawsuit.
Expert Witness: Meta Uses Confidential Health Data for Targeted Advertising
Meta sought to exclude plaintiffs’ expert witnesses who are likely to testify that the class should be certified.
One expert witness said that “Meta can and does programmatically identify healthcare provider websites and apps where it collects data via Meta Pixel and other Meta Business Tools.” Moreover, the expert said that Meta is apparently still classifying patients’ confidential healthcare information to use for targeted advertising purposes.
Expert Witness: Meta’s Data Collection Violated Medical Ethics and HIPAA
Another expert witness in the case is prepared to testify that Meta’s surveillance practices on healthcare-provider websites and apps violated medical ethics and the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA). In fact, according to the expert, Meta’s conduct is egregious enough to violate “traditional customs and norms for health information.”
Meta tried to get this expert’s opinions stricken from the record, but the court denied Meta’s motion to exclude.
Expert Witness: Patient Health Data Collected by Meta Is Extremely Valuable
Yet another expert witness is prepared to testify that the health information intercepted by Meta is extremely valuable and resulted in significant profits for the company. That expert relied on information from Meta to measure and reasonably approximate profits that the company generated from the use of class members’ data.
Meta attempted to get this expert witness’ testimony on the value of healthcare information excluded, but the court said that the expert used “methodologically sound models” to determine the value of the consumer data and that it could be admissible at trial. Previous cases and studies have also shown that health data used for targeted ads can generate significant revenues. For example, UC Irvine researchers conducted a study of California data brokers and observed that Google generated billions of dollars from targeted advertisements.
Unjust Enrichment
The court in In re Meta Pixel Healthcare also noted that evidence about the value of health data harvested by Meta may be relevant to one of the plaintiffs’ theories of liability: unjust enrichment. If Meta profited at the expense of patients by using their confidential health data, then class members may be entitled to a substantial restitutionary award.
Expert Witnesses: Health Information Is Sensitive and Should Not Be Used by Social Media Companies
Two more expert witnesses in the case provided research on the expectations that consumers and patients have about their private health information. According to these experts, people often think of health information as being more sensitive than other types of consumer data. Moreover, people typically do not find it acceptable for online communications with their healthcare providers to be intercepted by a social media company like Meta, used for marketing, and used to help that same social media company train their artificial intelligence (AI) models.
Meta tried to get the experts’ testimony excluded for being too broad and not based on studies dealing with privacy or healthcare data. Plaintiffs’ attorneys responded that the experts relied on both preexisting studies and their own original research to reach these conclusions. Ultimately, the court sided with the plaintiffs and denied Meta’s motion to exclude the expert opinions for class certification purposes.